Mindset Check: Are You Embracing Opportunities or Fearing Catastrophes?
We've all heard the advice, "Just be positive." While it can sometimes be irritating, there's a profound truth to it. Research has consistently shown that our mindset significantly impacts various aspects of our lives, from managing stress to healthy aging and coping with illness. A positive mindset tends to foster positive outcomes, while a negative one often leads to the opposite. The reason behind this influence lies in how our mindset shapes our emotions and behaviors, influencing everything from our eating habits to our social interactions.
Now, let's take a closer look at the COVID-19 pandemic. It has been a challenge for everyone, but some individuals have found it difficult to initiate or sustain healthy behaviors, while others have thrived under similar circumstances. Could these varying responses be attributed to different mindsets? A recent study published in Social Science & Medicine sought to explore this intriguing question.
How the Study Unfolded
The study was initiated in March 2020, at the beginning of the pandemic, to investigate how people's mindsets concerning the pandemic influenced their experiences throughout the crisis. The research involved 5,365 participants across all 50 states in the United States, ranging from 18 to 89 years of age. These individuals were carefully selected to ensure they hadn't tested positive for COVID-19 during the study period.
The participants were categorized into one of three "mindset" groups based on their most strongly identified statement:
1. Catastrophe: "The pandemic is a catastrophe that's wreaking havoc on our society."
2. Manageable: "The pandemic can be managed so that society can live life as normal."
3. Opportunity: "The pandemic can be an opportunity for our society to make positive changes." (Resonating with the concept of a growth mindset)
However, people could relate to more than one mindset to varying degrees. Over the course of the study, participants were assessed through questionnaires, measuring their emotional experiences, behaviours, the types of experiences they had, and their overall well-being in relation to the pandemic.
The Key Findings
As expected, participants who strongly embraced the catastrophe mindset were more likely to:
- Experience negative emotions.
- Engage in unhealthy behaviors, such as irregular sleep patterns and increased consumption of processed foods.
- Feel isolated and lonely.
- Encounter deteriorating physical and mental health.
- Report a lower quality of life.
On the other hand, those who strongly identified with the opportunity mindset were more likely to:
- Emotionally adapt better to the circumstances.
- Experience personal growth and stronger connections with others.
- Engage in healthier behaviours.
- Report a higher quality of life.
Remarkably, the manageable mindset displayed similar positive associations to the opportunity mindset. The study found that these mindsets at the beginning of the pandemic were predictive of the participants' quality of life six months later, mainly through their influence on behavioural and emotional patterns. In essence, the study concluded that people's mindsets about the pandemic were self-fulfilling in several aspects.
Insights for You
- Mindset Matters: Many individuals believe that their mindset has no bearing on their situation, but research demonstrates the significant power of mindset. When we find ourselves resisting or feeling overwhelmed by challenging circumstances, it's essential to recognize that our perspective can impact our well-being.
- Beyond Toxic Positivity: Working on our mindset doesn't imply promoting toxic positivity or downplaying legitimate concerns. Instead, it's about navigating difficult situations by acknowledging both the hardships and the potential opportunities within them.
- Embracing Challenges and Opportunities: The study underlines that the catastrophe and opportunity mindsets are not necessarily polar opposites. Seeing difficulties as challenges that can be managed while maintaining a positive outlook can lead to similar beneficial outcomes. It's about discovering the possibilities for growth, even within challenging circumstances.
Ready to let go of negative thoughts?
If you're seeking support to foster a more positive mindset during these trying times, consider coaching. Coaches can provide valuable guidance and strategies to help you develop a constructive outlook, even in the face of adversity, ultimately enhancing your overall well-being.
References:
Crum AJ, Akinola M, Martin A, Fath S. The role of stress mindset in shaping cognitive, emotional, and physiological responses to challenging and threatening stress. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping. 2017 Jan 25;30(4):379–95.
Levy B. Stereotype Embodiment: A Psychosocial Approach to Aging. Current directions in psychological science [Internet]. 2009;18(6):332–6.
Zion SR, Louis K, Horii R, Leibowitz K, Heathcote LC, Crum AJ. Making sense of a pandemic: Mindsets influence emotions, behaviors, health, and wellbeing during the COVID-19 pandemic. Social Science & Medicine. 2022 Mar; 114889.
The pandemic: Catastrophe or opportunity?. Precision Nutrition. (n.d.).
Important Links
Newsletter
Get exclusive stories, fresh insights and tips from Clarissa, plus podcast highlights, new tools, upcoming workshops, special offers, and more.
© 2025 Clardoon Coaching